How to get repeat customers for your online shop
Getting a new customer usually costs far more than getting an existing one to buy again. Repeat customers already trust you, they’re quicker to decide, and they’re more likely to recommend you. Yet many small shops put all their effort into new buyers. Here’s how to turn first orders into repeat ones.
1. Make the first order memorable
Repeat business starts with the first delivery. Fast dispatch, careful packaging and a product that matches the photos matter most. A short handwritten note or a thank-you card costs little and gets remembered. If something goes wrong, fix it quickly and generously: a problem solved well often creates a more loyal customer than no problem at all.
2. Know when people are likely to buy again
Look at your own sales. Do customers come back after a month, at Christmas, or when they run out? Consumables have a natural refill time. Gifts often bring people back for birthdays and the next Christmas. Time your follow-ups to match.
3. Get permission to keep in touch
On your own website, ask for permission to email customers at checkout, with a clear reason to say yes: early access to new products, restock alerts or occasional offers. UK rules on marketing emails apply, so make opting in clear and opting out easy.
On marketplaces, you can’t use buyers’ contact details for marketing. Amazon’s customer engagement tools let brand-registered sellers email customers who follow their brand, and Etsy lets you send targeted offers to shoppers who favourited your items. Use what each platform allows.
4. Send emails people want to open
You don’t need a complicated email programme. Three simple emails cover most of it:
- Welcome or thank-you: a few days after delivery, how to get the most from the product.
- Refill or "you might like": timed to when people usually buy again.
- New in or seasonal: new products, restocks or gift ideas.
Keep them short, personal and useful. One good email a month beats a weekly discount blast.
5. Reward loyalty without training people to wait for discounts
Constant discounts teach customers to wait for the next sale. Try rewards that feel special instead: early access to new products, a free gift on the second order, or free delivery for returning customers.
6. Make it easy to buy again
Make reordering effortless: a clear reorder link in emails, saved details on your website, and bundles or subscriptions for products people use up. On Amazon, keep your best-sellers in stock so returning buyers find them.
7. Track your repeat rate
Measure the share of orders from returning customers each quarter, and how long people take to buy again. If you sell on several channels, compare them: repeat buyers often behave very differently on your own site than on marketplaces.
Quarterly Snapshot puts every channel side by side, shows what’s holding your growth back and gives you a 90-day plan with one clear task a week. Your first review is free.
Frequently asked questions
What is a good repeat customer rate for an online shop?
It varies a lot by what you sell. Consumables and everyday products get far more repeat orders than gifts or one-off purchases, so compare yourself with your own past quarters.
Can I email my Amazon or Etsy customers?
Not for marketing using their contact details. Use the platform’s own tools, such as Amazon’s customer engagement tools for brand-registered sellers, and build your email list through your own website.
Do loyalty discounts work for small shops?
They can, but heavy discounts train customers to wait. Early access, a free gift on the second order or free delivery for returning customers protect your margin better.